Step 01
Building background knowledge
What is informality? How come there's data on it? Why would it relate to climate change? Why India?
What is informality?
In short: Informal work is employment outside the reach of formal labor protections: no written contract, no social security, no guaranteed minimum wage. In India, over 87% of the workforce is informal (ILO 2025).
In not so short:
Multifaceted definitons and perceptions
Informality is one of those concepts that can be talked about or quantified in many different ways. In fact, because countries have different laws, labor systems, and data available, informality needs to be quantified and judged in different ways. One core element to decide on when discussing informality is whether we are looking at firms or workers. My research focuses on workers, as this more closely aligns with my desire to observe the effects of climate change on livelihoods.
Nevertheless, the literature has provided much reflection on why firms decide to formalize or not. Ulyssea (2020) provides an account of those views, and argues that the three main paradigms are not contradictory, but rather highlight heterogeneous informal firms within the same economy. The backbone argument to those views is that formalization comes at a cost (administrative burden, regulatory constraints, financial barriers) which firms cannot or do not want to pay. The three main paradigms around informality are:
- The survivalist view: those informal firms would not break even if they were to become formal. They operate in a different bubble of the economy and do not compete with formal firms. They are too different, not from the same world.
- The unfair competition view: those informal firms would break even if they were to become formal, but benefit from remaining informal because of the avoided costs.
- The untapped entrepreneurial energy view: those informal firms would break even and net benefit from formalizing (e.g., they could expand), but remain informal because of formalization constraints.
Defining the Margin: Firms versus Individuals
One way to define informality is by what it lacks: state regulation, official registration, legal protections. When counting informality, one of the important choices to make in the definition is whether to look at individuals or firms (i.e., the intensive and extensive margins of informality).
Looking at informal firms, also referred to as the informal economy, the informal sector comprises small, unregistered, or unincorporated private enterprises that fall outside official regulatory and tax frameworks and do not maintain full accounts. In India, this maps to the historical distinction between the organized and unorganized sectors, where the organized segment is legally defined as non-agricultural units employing ten or more workers with power, or twenty or more without power. If we instead look at informality from an employment perspective, as codified by the International Labor Organization (ILO 2026), determining factors are workers' contracts and social safety net, encompassing all jobs—whether in formal enterprises, informal enterprises, or households—that lack basic social security coverage, paid annual leave, or protection against arbitrary dismissal. Some nuances are carried by the naming choices of informality measures: "individuals engaged in the informal economy" is more restrictive than "casual workers," which is generally more restrictive than "informal workers" (the ILO reports informality as the share of informal workers among all workers).
Data availability
Those structured definitions make informality data surprisingly tractable despite the phenomenon's hidden nature. Researchers exploit administrative and survey infrastructure to observe the margin directly. In Brazil, the carteira de trabalho allows researchers to precisely observe when workers transition out of legally binding formal contracts (Ulyssea 2020). In India, the tracking of this margin shifted structurally in 2017, when the NSSO replaced its quinquennial employment rounds with the Periodic Labour Force Survey (PLFS), introducing methodological adjustments better suited to capturing high-frequency labor dynamics. Other ways to capture informality is through household surveys, enterprise surveys and Value Added Per Worker estimates. Murthy (2019) presents the different approaches to measuring informality in India.
That said, aside from data availability, there are many factors when determining how to classify an activity or worker as informal (part-time work, workers with a contract but lacking social security benefits, ...) that complicate the evaluation of informality shares in a country or economy.
Is informality good or bad?
Depends who you ask.
| Pros | Cons | |
|---|---|---|
| Workers |
|
|
| Firms |
|
|
| Economy / Government / Policymaker |
|
|
*Informality and firm size are mutually reinforcing: informal firms cannot grow without risking inspection8, and small firms may remain informal because of high formalization costs2. Low managerial human capital may independently drive both outcomes. Measuring capital stocks across formal and informal firms remains methodologically challenging2.
**E.g., gender and settlement: Formal workers and informal employers tend to concentrate in urban areas, while own-account, unpaid family, and casual workers are predominantly rural5.
1 Abraham and Kesar (2025)2 LaPorta and Shleifer (2014)3 Jat and Ramaswami (2026)4 Dandapat et al. (2025)5 Sahoo and Neog (2017)6 Barrage and Schön (2026)7 Imbert and Ulyssea (2026)8 Ulyssea (2020)9 Meemken et al. (2025)10 Chiplunkar et al. (2024)11 Banerjee and Duflo (2011)12 Elgin et al. (2019)
India: a critical site to study informality
India offers a particularly instructive case for the study of climate shocks and informality. With the world's largest population and one of the highest informal employment rates globally — 87% as of 2025 (ILO 2025) — India concentrates an extraordinary share of the world's informal workforce. In 2017, informal enterprises accounted for 43% of non-farm GDP and 68% of all non-farm employment (Jat 2026). Agriculture, which employs roughly 42% of the labor force, remains deeply intertwined with informality, seasonal precarity, and subsistence livelihoods (ILO 2025), (Behera 2025). These structural conditions make India a critical site for studying the channels through which economic shocks propagate across formal and informal segments of the labor market.
Climate shocks in India
India is on the frontline of climate change. Heatwaves, erratic monsoons, and droughts increasingly disrupt the agricultural calendar that most rural households depend on. These shocks don't just harm crops — they ripple into labor markets, pushing workers toward informal, precarious jobs.
Acute exposure to climate risk
At the same time, India is acutely exposed to climate risk. The IPCC Sixth Assessment Report projects that extreme weather events will intensify and occur more frequently, generating growing economic and non-economic losses and damages (IPCC 2022b), (IPCC 2022a). Among South Asian nations, India is considered one of the most vulnerable, owing to its geographical exposure, population pressure, and developmental challenges (Bahinipati 2026), (Behera 2025), (Hammer 2022). Droughts and floods are particularly prominent threats: research documents a persistent and severe drought risk for India's population, with economic losses increasing steadily between 1964 and 2019 (Bahinipati 2026). Increasing mean temperatures (0.25°C per decade) and declining precipitation both exacerbate drought frequency and intensity and amplify flood magnitudes during extreme rainfall periods (Sharma 2025). Area and extreme rainfall thresholds are projected to increase by about 18(13)% and 58(50)% in the far future (2071–2100) under SSP5-8.5 (SSP2-4.5) (Konda 2024). Moreover, drought and flood losses exhibit significant regional disparity across Indian states, reflecting heterogeneous exposure, infrastructure capacity, and adaptive resources (Archana 2024). In sum, as climate change accelerates, the frequency, severity, and unpredictability of these events are projected to increase, making adaptation not merely a policy aspiration but an economic necessity.
Indian labor policy history
Informality in India is a result of structural policy decisions and limited educational attainments among population subgroups.
The ILO Employment Policy Department’s technical report (Mehrotra, 2019) provides a complete and comprehensive background on the origins and recent trends of informality in India. I recommend getting a look at it, but here are the essentials for what relates to my research:
- After about 200 years of colonial governance, India became independent from British rule in 1947. India launched Five-Year Plans with the goal of directing state resources into promoting balanced economic growth and modernizing infrastructure, heavy industry, and agriculture.
Three structural features of post-independence industrial strategy jointly depressed the demand for formal labor:- First, domestic savings were concentrated in heavy industry and away from agriculture. Agricultural workers, left with limited “funding”, sought work outside of agriculture. But modern industry is capital intensive, meaning it needs fewer workers for the same output. The formal industrial sector could not absorb migrants at anything close to the rate at which they were leaving agriculture :/ . With no unemployment benefits or savings cushion to fall back on, these workers had to find income immediately, and were instead absorbed into traditional services and micro-enterprises in the unorganized sector.
- Second, successive Industrial Policies made sure to protect small-scale enterprises by reserving the manufacturing of those goods precisely for those firms. Medium and large firms were excluded from these markets, while small enterprises had no incentive to grow, since growth would cost them their protected status and expose them to heavier regulatory obligations.
- The third factor was the emergence of a plethora of central and state labor laws, mostly applied to large enterprises and workers in the organized sector, with restrictions increasing with firm size. Those gave employers in the organized sector strong incentives to limit headcount rather than expand, as they created additional constraints and confusion, since they were often inconsistent.
The result was what economists call the "missing middle": a landscape polarized between a few capital-heavy giants and millions of informal micro-firms, with a structural void of medium-sized enterprises.
This is consistent with the broader theoretical literature: informal firms remain small precisely to avoid inspection or restrictions (Ulyssea 2020), while regulatory friction traps potentially productive firms outside the formal sector (La Porta 2014).
- Informality was further pushed by historically low educational attainment. In 2012, 30% of India's 485-million-strong workforce was illiterate, and 52% had only secondary-level schooling. A lower level of education hinders access to regular salaried employment; workers then cluster in casual wage labor and own-account self-employment, mapping to informal employment.
- More recent news: The share of agricultural workers fell in the early 2000s, consistent with a Lewisian structural transformation. Organized-sector employment grew, but the share of informal workers within that sector rose between 2000 and 2011-12, as firms substituted regular workers with contract labor to circumvent labor laws. Between 2011–12 and 2017–18, informality — defined as employment without a written contract, paid leave, health benefits, or social security — declined modestly in aggregate, falling from 92.4% to 90.7% of the workforce. This overall reduction masks divergent sectoral dynamics: informality contracted within the organized sector while simultaneously increasing in the unorganized sector, even as the unorganized sector’s share of total employment shrank (Murthy, 2019). The precise picture therefore depends on which definition of informality one adopts.
For more details, check out the ILO paper or the thesis manuscript.